I can’t say enough good things about this shop and this product! It is absolutely perfect! Amazing quality and the customer service was wonderful. They were so kind with letting me add and change a couple things to my order. It arrived on time and came in a nice box that is perfect for gifting. I highly recommend. Thank you so much for creating such a wonderful memory for my family!
Etsy buyer · Etsy review · Mar 2026
★★★★★
Matt did an amazing job again. I had him create a lure for when we got pregnant with our first child, now that we are trying for our second, I had him do another one. I went with a different lure but wanted to match the same theme as the first one as well as the quote. I am beyond happy with his work!
Tiffine · Etsy review · May 2026
★★★★★
So happy with how it turned out! My dad is big time fisherman so the lure was the perfect way to surprise him that he is going to be a grandpa!
Chelsea · Etsy review · Jun 2026
★★★★★
It’s perfect! & when I reached out to Matthew to see how long it would be for it to be shipped, he replied almost immediately and got it shipped asap.
Juliana · Etsy review · Jul 2026
★★★★★
Cute baby announcement gift. Shipping was quick and personalization was accurate.
Jayne · Etsy review · Jun 2026
★★★★★
We loved this!! We are so excited to give it to my husbands dad.
Alyssa · Etsy review · Oct 2026
Reviews from my Etsy shop, PromoLures, shown as written. Same maker, same lures. Seller ranking from eRank.
About this gift
Tell him there's a new fishing buddy on the way. This hand-painted lure reads "New Fishing Buddy" with the arrival you choose, like On the Way!, Coming Soon, or the month the baby is due.
Use it as the pregnancy reveal itself, or as a keepsake for the dad-to-be once the news is out. Add a short message on the second side if you'd like.
The Complete Gift Set adds a display stand, a gift tin, and a note card printed with your message.
Choose how it arrives
Lure Only
$22.95
The personalized lure on its own, ready to give or display.
Lure & Display Stand
$29.95
The lure plus a display stand, so it can sit on a desk or shelf.
Lure & Gift Tin
$29.95
The lure packed in a gift tin, ready to hand over.
Complete Gift Set
$44.95
The lure, display stand, gift tin, and a note card printed with your message.
How ordering works
Choose a package
Pick the lure on its own or a gift-ready set with a stand, tin, or both.
Add the words
Type the name and an optional date or message. It's printed exactly as you type it.
I make it by hand
Your lure is painted, personalized, and sealed in my Cape Cod workshop, then shipped in 3 to 5 business days.
The details
Size
About 4 × 2 in, hooks included
Hardware
Comes with treble hooks. This larger lure isn't offered as a keyring.
How it's made
Hand-airbrushed lure blank, printed personalization, and a clear epoxy topcoat
Ships
Made and shipped in 3 to 5 business days, plus transit time
Shipping
$5.95, or free on orders of $39 or more (the Complete Gift Set ships free)
Questions
Will the spelling be exactly what I type?
Yes. Your text is printed exactly as you type it, including capitals and punctuation, so please check it before you order. If I make a mistake, I'll replace the lure.
When will it ship?
Each lure is made to order and ships in 3 to 5 business days. Delivery time depends on the shipping service and your location, so order early if you have a date in mind.
What goes on the note card?
The Complete Gift Set includes a printed note card. Type your message (up to 200 characters) when you order, and I'll print it on the card.
How much is shipping?
Shipping is $5.95, or free on orders of $39 or more. The Complete Gift Set always ships free.
Can I order in bulk or get a custom design?
Yes. For wedding parties, teams, company gifts, or anything five lures or more, or for a design that isn't listed, email me at matt@legacylurecompany.com. Tell me what you have in mind and when you need it, and I'll get back to you.
